Looking north from Stone Jug Road, towards Dare's (now Ramsey's) Hill. The former farmstead of George and Mary Squibb is at right, though their original home (a 2-room log cabin) probably no longer exists on the property. The present house appears to have been built around 1900. This road and a nearby creek (running under the road to the right, not shown), as well as Ramsey's Hill, probably formed the boundaries of the original 87-acre Squibb property.
On the morning of Monday, June 18, 1866, George Snelbaker (grandson and neighbor of George and Mary Squibb), went to the Squibb cabin to borrow an auger. Arriving there he discovered their badly-mauled bodies, along with that of their 11-year-old granddaughter Sarah Emma Seifert who lived with them. George was found on the porch, unconscious and bleeding from wounds to his head (from an axe or hammer) from which he died later that day. Mary and Sarah Emma Seifert (the child of George and Mary's daughter Maria) were both found in the kitchen, similarly injured; Sarah was already dead, but Mary lived on painfully for another week. During that time she appeared to be the only surviving witness to the crime, but she had lost the ability to speak or even write. Investigators determined that she may have enough mental acuity left to reveal the perpetrator(s). They devised a way for Mary to determine the killer: they read to her the names of local neighbors and other family associates and relations, asking her to squeeze the investigator's hand when the killer's name was mentioned. After repeating the list multiple times, they found that Mary would squeeze the hand each time William Donovan's name was recited.
William "Irish Bill" Donovan, a neighbor living about 1 mile north of the Squibb property, was sued by George Squibb several years earlier. One of Squibb's cows got loose from its enclosure and wandered onto Donovan's property, where he viciously beat the animal to death. Following a trial, the York County court awarded Squibb money to recover the loss of his cow. Reportedly, Donovan was angry about the judgement, thinking it unfair and fearing for his own family's economic survival (as he was reported to have had other suits pending at the same time). According to eyewitnesses in the murder trial in which Donovan entered a "not guilty" plea, Donovan had on multiple occasions swore revenge on George Squibb "if it is ten years afterward". When investigators searched Donovan's property they located a blood-stained axe; newspapers variously reported it as having been found under his porch or in his stable. It is unknown whether the blood was tested to distinguish if it were human or animal; certainly no fingerprints would have been taken at that early date of 1866.
Other suspects in the case--including a traveling peddler couple, and two of Donovan's friends who had come to his house from Harrisburg that weekend--were acquitted and determined not to have been involved. Donovan maintained his innocence all the while, but was eventually convicted of the murders and hanged at York in 1868. His last words were reported to be, "You are hanging an innocent man."
The 1876 map of Warrington Twp., York Co., PA, showing the location of the Squibb residence (then owned by their daughter, Caroline Squibb). The Squibb house must have stood in the same vicinity as the property's present house and outbuildings. An article detailing the murder investigation from Frank Leslie's Illustrated Newspaper (July 14, 1866) described the Squibb house as being "about 150 yards from a main road" (Stone Jug Rd.) Note the next two buildings to the west of the Squibb house; these are both photographed below.
Looking northeast at the former Squibb property, Ramsey's Hill in background. Today a farm still occupies the place. The driveway, treeline and field lines are probably similar to when George Squibb owned the property.
Looking northeast at a collapsed stone house, just west of the Squibb property on Stone Jug Road. In 1876 this building was the dwelling of "F. Myers". Myers was the last name of Caroline Squibb's child, Mary Jane.
Looking northwest at a small wood cabin only about 50 feet west of the collapsed stone building. It was owned by "J. Bash" in 1876. This building appears to date from the first half of the nineteenth century, and was probably a one-or two-room house. Note the stone foundation. It may very well be constructed of logs beneath the clapdoards, and appears to be similar in size to George and Mary Squibb's cabin home.
Looking northeast at the leaning cabin, one really doubts that this house will be standing much longer. Judging from the many "No Trespassing" signs appearing all over the property, unfortunately it seems that unwanted visitors have frequented the place. But with such a tragic history, one can understand why. The tree at right must be well over 100 years old, and may even have been alive when the murder was committed in 1866.



